Latest News

HMRC wins Rangers ‘big tax case’ ruling

Added on 23 July 2017 - 7:10 'Viewed 55 views times.
Image copyright Getty Images

Analysis by Chris McLaughlin, BBC Sport

There will undoubtedly be calls for the football authorities to act following this judgement.

A Scottish Premier League investigation headed by Lord Nimmo Smith found Rangers guilty of not registering players properly and the company was fined in 2013.

Nimmo Smith’s judgement was made at a time when the EBT scheme was deemed acceptable by a tax tribunal and he resisted calls for the club to be stripped of honours won during the years the scheme was in operation, saying “Rangers FC did not gain any unfair competitive advantage from the contraventions of the SPL Rules.”

It’s unlikely the football authorities will have much appetite to sanction another investigation but that won’t stop some calling for just that.

A spokesman said the Scottish Premier Football League will “take time to examine the ‎judgement in detail and to consider any implications.”

What does the ruling mean?

The result is a major victory for HMRC in its attempts to recoup tax from thousands of other companies which ran EBTs and similar schemes, which were the subject of a crackdown in legislation enacted in December 2010.

HMRC could now issue “follower notices”, which would demand payment from companies who ran similar schemes.

‘Discretionary bonuses’

A number of football clubs in England fall into this category.

A settlement opportunity in light of the 2010 legislation ran out in July 2015 and other firms could now be liable for major sums.

In a written judgment, the judges said: “The sums paid to the trustee of the Principal Trust for a footballer constituted the footballer’s earnings. The risk that the trustee might not set up a sub-trust or give a loan of the sub-trust funds to the footballer does not alter the nature of the payments made to the trustee of the Principal Trust.

“The discretionary bonuses made available to RFC’s employees through the same trust mechanisms also fall within the tax charge as these were given in respect of the employee’s work.

“Payment to the Principal Trust should have been subject to deduction of income tax under the PAYE regulations.”

Image copyright SNS (Scotland) Image caption Sir David Murray took control of Rangers in 1988 and sold the club in 2011

The EBT scheme was administered by the Murray Group, then majority shareholder of the Glasgow club, from 2001 to 2009.

In February 2012, Rangers, which was then run by Craig Whyte, went into administration over a separate tax debt and the tax authority rejected a creditors agreement in June of that year.

The supreme court decision is in relation to Murray Group companies, including the liquidated company RFC 2012, and not the current owners at Ibrox.

The result will mean the creditors of RFC 2012 will receive less money from the pot collected by liquidators BDO, as HMRC will now be owed more money.

‘Creditor dismay’

Former Rangers chairman Sir David Murray said he was “hugely disappointed” with the verdict, which he said ran counter to the legal advice which was consistently provided to Rangers Football Club.

He said: “It should be emphasised that there have been no allegations made by HMRC or any of the courts that the club was involved in tax evasion, which is a criminal offence.

“The decision will be greeted with dismay by the ordinary creditors of the club, many of which are small businesses, who will now receive a much lower distribution in the liquidation of the club, which occurred during the ownership of Craig Whyte, than may otherwise have been the case.”

In a statement, HMRC said: “This decision has wide-ranging implications for other avoidance cases and we encourage anyone who has tried to avoid tax on their earnings to now agree with us the tax owed.

“HMRC will always challenge contrived arrangements that try to deliver tax advantages never intended by parliament.”

Rangers liquidators BDO said it believed taking the case to the Supreme Court had been the correct course of action “given the significance of the matter”.

It said: “We will now engage with HMRC on adjudicating its claim.

“Further advice and guidance will be provided to creditors in due course.”

The Scottish FA said that, after examining the judgement, it would take no further disciplinary action.

It said it had been advised it was unlikely the Scottish FA would be successful pursuing a complaint about whether disciplinary rules could have been breached.

It added that, even if successful, any sanctions available to a judicial panel would be limited in their scope.

Meanwhile, Celtic said they were sure that the football authorities would review their findings that Rangers gained no sporting advantage from the tax-avoidance scheme.

A league commission fined Rangers in 2013 but did not strip the club of any titles they had won during the years the scheme was in operation.

Celtic disagreed with that ruling at the time, and said the Supreme Court judgement “re-affirms that view.”

Comment the Message.

No Comment

You must be logged in to post comments..

Might interest you

It took nine games to show how poisonous Phil-Carmelo era was

On a night Carmelo Anthony got ejected for a flagrant 2 foul in a Thunder loss, Kristaps Porzingis notched 40 points. On a night Anthony was tossed for what looked more like a regular offensive foul than an automatic flagrant ejection, Porzingis started getting superstar calls from the refs during his spectacular second-half rampage against the Pacers. On a night the Thunder fell to 4-5, the Knicks moved to 5-4, winners of five of six. Sunday truly felt like a seminal evening at the Garden, a night the Anthony era could not have felt more distant. A 7-foot-3 superstar has emerged before our eyes and a French rookie point guard named Frank Ntilikina looked beyond his years in the crucible of his first crunch-time action, as the Knicks rallied from a 19-point hole late in the third. One week ago, Enes Kanter stated …

Big East preview: The threats are coming for Villanova

If only the Big East had broken up earlier. After winning a share of just one league title in 16 seasons, Villanova enters the fifth season of the reconfigured Big East as the only regular season champion in the new league ’s history. The Wildcats will be the favorite to take the title home again, though Seton Hall and Xavier could be just as dangerous come March, when the Big East will attempt to improve upon last season ’s mark of sending seven teams to the NCAA Tournament. Big East Rankings 1. Villanova 2. Xavier 3. Seton Hall 4. Providence 5. Creighton 6. Marquette 7. St. John ’s 8. Butler 9. DePaul 10. Georgetown Big East Preseason Player of the Year: Trevon Bluiett, F, Xavier There may not be a more polished scoring wing in the country than the 6-foot-6 senior. As potent on the ball as off of it, while…

Florida road trip may have been just what J.T. Miller needed

J.T. Miller did, in fact, make the trip back to New York on Sunday with the Rangers. But the way the winger played on their two-game road trip through Florida, he may have wanted to keep skating in the Sunshine State. Miller scored the game-winning goal in Thursday ’s overtime win over the Lightning before tallying three assists, including one on Kevin Shattenkirk ’s game-winner, in another overtime win Saturday against the Panthers. “These could have been two of the stronger games he ’s played so far this year,” coach Alain Vigneault said Sunday. “We need him to be a force. He ’s got tons of potential and he ’s a veteran player. We need him to play like a true veteran and a true leader on this team.” The 24-year-old Miller now has 11 points in the past 10 games and is tied for the team lead with…

Islanders get record-setting night from rookie center

There was some sloppy play Sunday night by the Islanders that left coach Doug Weight frustrated after the game, but there was at least one thing that was clean, crisp and quick: Mathew Barzal. The Islanders ’ 20-year-old center continued to break out, setting a single-game franchise rookie record with five assists to spark a 6-4 win over the Avalanche at Barclays Center. “His speed is unbelievable,” Dennis Seidenberg said. “He ’s gliding. It ’s not looking like he ’s moving, but he ’s just actually flying.” Two of Barzal ’s assists were highlight-reel helpers on Jordan Eberle goals, fueling the Islanders (8-5-1) to their sixth win in the last eight games. “It was kind of a night where everything went right,” said Barzal, who became the first NHL rookie since 2011 to tally five assists. “I…

Henrik Lundqvist is back in form and Rangers are dangerous

This was never going to be a throw-away year. Those don ’t exist for the Rangers, not while Henrik Lundqvist remains in nets. But whether it was explicitly described or just understood, this was tabbed as a year of transition for the perennial postseason contender. This was far more than just another retool on the fly when Dan Girardi and Derek Stepan were sent away — and still, no one quite expected it to be as bad as the 1-5-2 getaway, just as ugly as it sounds. The heat rose around the front office, even if the temperature was likely never as high inside its own building as it was perceived to be looking in. Which is not to say that a pressure valve wasn ’t released after this tidy little three-game winning streak, which included the Rangers most impressive, full-game performance of the season, a 2-1 over…

Blow up the Giants

They ’re all hired to be fired, head coaches and general managers — and Ben McAdoo and Jerry Reese are halfway toward firing themselves. A 1-7 record, of course, is more than half bad. A 2-14 mark would be historically bad. Tick … tick … tick. It looks over, and it feels over. And if Rams 51, Giants 17 is the product Giants fans are forced to endure, it should be over. Regime change isn ’t only in the air, it is howling across East Rutherford. 51-17! “I think it speaks for itself, doesn ’t it?” John Mara told N.J.com afterward. Son of Wellington was lucky he wasn ’t alive to see Bears 56, Giants 7 at the Polo Grounds, when the Giants defense made Sid Luckman look like Jared Goff. The Giants have turned MetLife Stadium into MetDeath Stadium … flocks of boobirds and empty seats everywhere. This w…